Monday, March 14, 2011

Why is Voice Quality on Smartphones Lacking?

There's no question that phones have evolved throughout the years, from old dial phones to brick cellphones and now smartphones. I personally use my LG Ally for dozens of different things beyond simply picking it up to call someone - texting, calculating, budgeting, entertainment, and more. With so many other features it seems that the interface and quality of the phone itself has fallen on the backburner.

This article from NPR addresses the issue. Such a dizzying array of features present themselves to today's smartphone buyer that a simple question like "How's the voice quality?" can be drowned out by the size of the SD card, the apps that come preloaded, and the number of megapixels on the camera.

Image from my Flickr stream
I don't call people much; I text, email or chat on Google Voice. However, voice quality is very important for me for those times when I do need to call, particularly since I don't have a landline to turn to. So far, I haven't had any complaints about my phone's voice quality. I've simply maxed out the volume and it's useable that way.

According to the NPR article, "Consumer Reports gave most smart phones 'fair' voice quality ratings in its latest reviews. [...] That's in stark contrast to the "excellent" ratings given to display, Web browsing and even battery life features on smart phones."

So what's to blame for the lack of good voice quality on smartphones when manufacturers pay careful attention to things such as battery life and screen resolution?

There seem to be a few factors, according to the article: less room in the device itself for a good speaker; texting and video phone use on the rise; and the fact that cellphones rely on carrier coverage beyond what's built into the device.

A J.D. Power and Associates report linked to in the article has some specifics on particular carriers and how they rank in geographic regions of the US. For example, Verizon Wireless is highest in my area, the Southwest, in terms of "fewer customer-reported problems with dropped calls, initial connections and interference, compared with the regional averages."

It's always wise to research not only the device but the carrier before committing to a phone or a contract. How much emphasis do you put on voice quality when shopping for a phone?


  1. I know they still post the hearing aid compatibility ratings but I've noticed over time that few of the phones have the maximum compatibility capable of some of the previous phones.

    Do you not bluetooth your phone to your hearing aid? Or you bypass your hearing aid when listening to the phone?

    My wife gave up on her new hearing aids and went back to her original analog hearing aids aftering having so many problems with her digital ones.

  2. Hi techgeekdad- I totally forgot to mention hearing aid ratings, so thanks for that. I also noticed that many phones when I went in to find mine are only M3.

    I do have the Streamer to use with my phone, but I don't carry it with me so I only use it if I am at home. I just listen to the phone with my hearing aids in. It works okay most of the time :)


All comments on my blog are moderated, and I reserve the right not to publish any comments for any reason. This blog is set up so that anyone can comment. If you have trouble, email me, or check Blogger's help section.